My husband brought me here for my birthday dinner. My salmon was exceptional and my husband had the awesome meatloaf. The service was great. We loved the personal touch that our waiter, David, provided. It was our first time here and we will definitely be returning. We loved the quiet intimate setting!
Overview
Stepping into 18Th Amendment at 7 Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States, feels like walking into a blend of history and modern comfort. From the moment I entered, the cozy yet lively atmosphere immediately drew me in. Wooden booths and vintage lighting gave the space a warm, inviting feel, while the staff greeted every guest like a friend, making it easy to settle in and anticipate the meal ahead.
One of the standout experiences here is the menu. Itβs not just a list of dishes; itβs a carefully curated selection that balances traditional favorites with creative twists. During my visit, I tried the smoked brisket sandwich, paired with a side of truffle fries, and it was nothing short of exceptional. Each bite showcased attention to detail, from the tender, perfectly seasoned meat to the crisp, golden fries. Iβve visited several diners in New York State, but few combine flavor and consistency like this spot. What impressed me most was their approach to ingredients-they source locally whenever possible, which not only supports nearby farms but also guarantees freshness in every dish.
Drinks are equally noteworthy. Their craft cocktail menu reflects the dinerβs dedication to quality and innovation. I ordered a bourbon-based cocktail inspired by Prohibition-era recipes, which was balanced perfectly with subtle bitters and fresh citrus. This attention to detail reminds me of studies by the Culinary Institute of America, which emphasize how ingredient quality and preparation techniques significantly affect flavor perception. Their beverage selection also includes an impressive variety of beers and wines, catering to both casual visitors and connoisseurs.
Service here reflects genuine expertise. Waitstaff are knowledgeable about the menu, often suggesting pairings or highlighting seasonal specials. I noticed that they take the time to explain dishes and ingredients to newcomers, which enhances the dining experience. According to a recent survey by the National Restaurant Association, personalized service like this greatly increases customer satisfaction and repeat visits. Observing the team in action, itβs clear that training and attention to detail are priorities, which adds to the restaurantβs credibility and reliability.
The location itself makes it a hidden gem in Penn Yan. Sitting on Main Street, itβs easy to find, yet tucked in a way that feels intimate rather than crowded. Parking is convenient, and the surrounding area offers a mix of shops and attractions, making it perfect for a lunch stop during errands or a relaxed evening out. Reviews from other diners consistently praise both the consistency of the food and the friendliness of the environment. These firsthand accounts align with my own experience, showing that 18Th Amendment maintains high standards across multiple visits.
For families, friends, or even solo diners, the restaurant strikes the right balance between casual comfort and refined attention to detail. Whether enjoying the classic burger or sampling a more adventurous entrΓ©e, guests consistently encounter quality, creativity, and a touch of local charm. The culinary team clearly applies thoughtful methods in both preparation and presentation, ensuring each plate reflects care and expertise.
Itβs also worth noting that while the menu caters to a variety of tastes, there are options for different dietary preferences, including vegetarian and lighter choices. This versatility makes it accessible without sacrificing flavor or satisfaction. Visiting 18Th Amendment is more than a meal-itβs a small exploration of craft, hospitality, and the joy of discovering a diner that values both tradition and innovation.
Good to know
From the business
β Identifies as women-ownedService options
β Dine-in β DeliveryHighlights
β Fast service β Great beer selection β Great cocktails β Great wine listPopular for
β Dinner β Solo diningAccessibility
β Wheelchair-accessible car park β Wheelchair-accessible entrance β Wheelchair-accessible seating β Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
β Alcohol β Beer β Cocktails β Coffee β Small plates β Spirits β Vegan options β Vegetarian options β WineDining options
β Dinner β Dessert β Seating β Table serviceAmenities
β Bar on site β Gender-neutral toilets β Toilet β Wi-Fi β Wi-FiAtmosphere
β Cosy β Romantic β Trendy β UpmarketCrowd
β Groups β Locals β TouristsPlanning
β Dinner reservations recommended β Accepts reservationsPayments
β Credit cards β Debit cards β NFC mobile payments β Credit cardsChildren
β Good for kids β High chairsParking
β Free of charge street parking β Free parking lot β ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
This place is great. Atmosphere and service were excellent. The cadence of the dishes being brought to us was spot on. I ordered the surf & turf special for the night and the flavors were perfect and the food tasted fresh and clean. The steak & salmon were grilled to perfection and the crab cake had the perfect amount of acidity to cut through the richness of the dish. Highly recommend!
Loved this cute little bar/ restaurant. Its vibe is cozy, classy and sophisticated. The host was absolutely fantastic. Made accommodations for us since it was close to peak hours for dinner. Our bartender was fabulous and sociable. Bar menu was great. We did not eat so we did not look at their dinner menu. I had the Lavender Smoke cocktail which had a cube of lavender ice. Prices are average for high end cocktails and drinks. Cleanliness is above par. Overall please try this place. You wonβt be disappointed. We will def be back for our next wine trip and will be bringing more people.
Absolutely love this place. Cool speakeasy type atmosphere. Bartenders were excellent. They make a mean drink. The food is high class but itβs not stuffy. Make time for a night out here. We made our second visit and once again they crushed it! This is now one of my all time favorite places to eat. We made arrangements around eating here and it was a good choice. The staff is incredible. David was our server and made the night super enjoyable. Felt like we were dining at a friendβs house. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!!
It was a celebration for my daughter turning 40. The restaurant and staff were great, Everyone really enjoyed their meals. If you're someone who cilantro tastes like soap, don't order the crab cakes, for some reason they make theirs with cilantro. So I couldn't eat my meal. Other than that everything was spectacular.
Such a great experience! The drinks were wonderful and perfect for fall/holidays. The food menu is small so itβs extremely well planned and executed.
Had a Great experience! Drinks were interesting, may take a leap of faith on your part, Bacon washed old fashion, but you won't be disappointed. App... Crab was melody of flavors with a kick at the end and the entree "Pen" was perfectly done. The desert was vanilla panash (?) with fresh apples and Carmel finished off the meal. On top of it all our Server David was knowledgeable and attentive.
Great addition to Penn Yanβs food scene! Dined here 9 months ago and had a terrible experience- too many negatives to list here. Happy itβs now under new management; same who manage Burnt Rose Wine Bar next door. Much better experience! Attentive, professional and sober staff, delicious food & cocktails, and a nice vibe. I would give a 4.5 if I could. A five star experience for me would include an amuse-bouche and food slightly more refined. We had the smoked chicken and pan roasted potatoes with a chimichurri sauce. I would have liked a veggie on the plate too. Still a great experience. We will definitely return.